Overtrading: how to know if you trade too much

Kévin KOUSSOUGBE
· 5 min read

In the morning, you plan two or three trades. In the evening, you count eleven. None of them was really in your plan after the third one, yet each felt justified at the time. This drift has a name: overtrading. It almost never shows on a single trade. It shows in your history.

What is overtrading?

Overtrading means taking more trades than your plan allows, or trades that do not meet your entry criteria. It is not about an absolute number: a scalper can take 30 trades a day while following the plan, while a swing trader who takes 4 in one day may be overtrading.

So the real question is not "how many?" but "why this one?". If the answer is boredom, frustration, the urge to win it back or the fear of missing a move, your plan is no longer in charge.

The most common causes

  • Boredom. The market is quiet, nothing matches your setup, and having no position becomes uncomfortable. You end up "finding" a trade.
  • Revenge after a loss. You keep going to win back what you just lost. That is revenge trading, and it quickly turns into a burst of trades.
  • Euphoria after wins. Two or three winners in a row make everything look easy. Your criteria loosen.
  • FOMO. Every missed move pushes you into the next one, even late.
  • A money target. "I need to make €100 today" pushes you to trade until you hit the number, whatever the market does.

The signs that do not lie

You may be overtrading if you recognise yourself in several of these situations:

  1. You take several trades in less than an hour, often on different instruments.
  2. Your last trades of the day are your worst. Fatigue and frustration degrade the quality of your entries.
  3. You cannot explain the setup of some of your trades when you read your journal again.
  4. Fees weigh heavily. Commissions and spreads add up on every trade, winner or loser.
  5. You feel drained after a session, even without a big result.

A single sign proves nothing. Several recurring signs do.

How to measure overtrading in your history

Gut feeling is not enough: you remember the big trades, not the small ones taken on reflex. Three simple measurements, over at least one month of trades:

1. Compare your results by number of trades in the day. Split your days into two groups: days when you kept to your planned number, and days when you went over it. Calculate the average result of each group. If the "over" days are clearly worse, you have your answer.

2. Look at the rank of the trade in the day. Calculate the average result of your 1st trade, your 2nd, your 3rd, and so on. For many traders, quality drops after a certain rank. That rank is your natural limit.

3. Spot the bursts. Several trades opened in a very short time rarely all come from analysis. Isolate them and calculate their profit factor separately: if it is clearly lower than the rest, these trades are costing you.

These numbers are indicators to read over a large enough sample. Over one week, chance weighs too much to conclude anything.

What overtrading really costs

The most visible cost is fees: more trades means more commissions and spreads, which reduce your result even when you win.

The less visible cost is the average quality of your trades. Your expectancy per trade comes from your best setups. Every trade taken outside the plan has an unknown expectancy, often lower. Adding mediocre trades to good ones pulls the average down, even if the number of winners goes up.

In a prop firm challenge, overtrading is even riskier: a burst of small losses can hit the daily loss limit within an hour.

5 rules to stop overtrading

  1. Set a maximum number of trades per day in your plan, based on your statistics (the rank after which your results drop). Once you reach it, the session is over.
  2. Take a break after every closed trade. Fifteen minutes away from the screen is often enough to break the chain.
  3. Stop after two losses in a row. That is when frustration takes over. See also how to stop trading tilt.
  4. Write the setup before you enter. One sentence in your journal: if you cannot write it, you do not enter.
  5. Replace the money target with an execution target. "Follow my plan on every trade" rather than "make €100".

Spotting overtrading automatically

Running these calculations by hand takes time, and it is exactly the kind of task people drop. Tradeora imports your MT4/MT5 history and automatically flags trades taken in a burst: a trade is flagged when it is part of at least 5 trades opened within one hour. You can filter these trades in your history to see what they make or cost you. If your account is synced, an "Overtrading detected" alert lets you know. You can also ask the AI Coach whether you trade too much, and on which days or at which hours. It is a tool to analyse your own history, not a buy or sell signal.

Frequently asked questions

How many trades per day is too many?

There is no universal number: it depends on your strategy and your timeframe. The right number is the one your plan sets, based on your own statistics. Going over that number is what signals overtrading.

Is overtrading always a losing habit?

No. Some overtrading days end positive, which reinforces the habit. Over time, trades taken outside the plan usually have lower quality and extra fees: it is the average that suffers.

What is the difference with revenge trading?

Revenge trading is one possible cause of overtrading: you keep trading to win back a loss. But you can overtrade without a prior loss, out of boredom or euphoria.

Want to know if you trade too much, with numbers to back it up? Free 14-day trial, no credit card required.

This content is educational and is not investment advice. Past results do not guarantee future results. Trading involves a risk of capital loss.