Best trading journal: an honest comparison (Excel, Edgewonk, Tradezella, TraderSync, Tradeora)
You are looking for the best trading journal and every site tells you it is theirs. We also make a trading journal (Tradeora), so take this comparison for what it is: a publisher’s view. We wrote it with one simple rule: only state what the tools’ own sites show, and say clearly when a competitor will suit you better.
There is no best journal in absolute terms. There is the journal that fits your platform, your budget and what you want to learn from your trades.
The 6 criteria that really matter
Before comparing names, set your criteria. They decide.
- Your platform. If you trade on MetaTrader 4 or 5 (forex, indices, gold), check that the journal imports your trades without retyping. If you trade stocks or options with a US broker, the options are different.
- Automatic import. A journal you fill in by hand gets abandoned after three weeks. That is the first reason journals fail, as explained in how to keep an effective trading journal.
- What it shows you without effort. Basic statistics (win rate, profit factor, drawdown) are everywhere. The difference is what the tool spots on its own: revenge trading, overtrading, outsized losses, weak hours.
- The real price. Compare monthly and yearly prices, the plans, and what is reserved for the expensive plans.
- The trial. You only know whether a journal suits you after using it with your own trades. A free trial or a money-back guarantee changes everything.
- Language and payment. An interface in your language and a local payment method matter more than you think when you are starting out.
The comparison table
| Criterion | Excel / Google Sheets | Edgewonk | Tradezella | TraderSync | Tradeora | | --------- | ---------------------- | ---------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- | | Price | Free | $35/month or $197/year | $35 to $99/month depending on plan | About $30 to $80/month depending on plan | $19/month or $189/year | | Trial | — | 14-day money-back guarantee | Not stated on the pricing page | Short trial reported by reviews, to check | 14 days free, no card | | MT4 / MT5 | Retyping or copy-paste | Brokers listed on their site | Yes (sync or file) | To check | Yes (sync or statement) | | Strengths | Total freedom | Very deep analysis | Replay, backtesting, 500+ brokers | Stocks, futures, options | Automatic mistake detection, AI Coach | | Language | Your language | English | English | English | English and French |
Prices read on the publishers’ sites on 12 November 2026 (TraderSync: public reviews, because their site blocks automated reading). Prices change often, always check the official site.
Excel or Google Sheets: free, but everything is on you
A spreadsheet is still a good starting point. You choose your columns and formulas, and you understand every number. We even published a free Excel template.
The limits come quickly: retyping every trade, copy errors, and above all a spreadsheet will never tell you "you lose more on Friday evenings" or "your losses double after two losses in a row". You have to build every analysis yourself.
For whom: the beginner who takes fewer than 20 trades a month and wants to learn to measure themselves.
Edgewonk: depth of analysis
Edgewonk is a well-known, very complete journal. It offers advanced tools such as MAE/MFE analysis, a performance simulator, a trade management optimizer and "tilt" tracking. Its pricing page shows $35 a month or $197 a year, with a 14-day money-back guarantee rather than a free trial.
For whom: the trader who wants to dig into their statistics in detail and is willing to spend time setting up their analyses. See our detailed Tradeora vs Edgewonk comparison.
Tradezella: the broadest
Tradezella claims more than 500 connected brokers and platforms, including MT4 and MT5, plus trade replay and a backtesting module. Three plans are shown: $35, $59 and $99 a month (or $315, $531 and $891 a year).
For whom: the trader who uses several brokers or markets and wants to replay trades or test strategies in the same tool. See Tradeora vs Tradezella.
TraderSync: built for stocks and options
TraderSync is widely used by stock, futures and options traders, with imports from many brokers and an AI assistant whose access depends on the plan. Public prices reported by reviews range from about $30 to $80 a month. MetaTrader support is to be checked on their site.
For whom: the stock or options trader with a connected broker. See Tradeora vs TraderSync.
Tradeora: focused on MetaTrader and your mistakes
This is our tool, so here is what it does, and what it does not do.
What it does: it imports your MT4/MT5 history (automatic sync or statement), computes your statistics, your drawdown, your results by hour and by day, and spots your behavior mistakes on its own: revenge trading, overtrading, outsized losses (more than 3 times your median loss), trades without a stop. A weekly review and an AI Coach (10 free messages, then packs from $2.50) answer questions about your own trades. It costs $19 a month or $189 a year, can be paid by Mobile Money in XOF, and comes with a 14-day trial with no credit card.
What it does not do: no trade replay, no backtesting, and no connection to US stock brokers. If you need those, one of the tools above will suit you better.
For whom: the MetaTrader trader (forex, indices, gold, prop firm accounts) who wants their mistakes shown to them without building the analyses themselves.
How to choose in 3 questions
- You trade on MetaTrader and are new to journaling? Start with a free trial using your real trades, and see what the tool teaches you in the first week.
- You want very deep analysis? Edgewonk or Tradezella.
- You trade US stocks or options? TraderSync or Tradezella.
Whatever the tool, the rule is the same: a journal only helps if you read it back. Plan 10 minutes a week for a review, and one thing to fix the following week.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a free trading journal?
Yes: an Excel or Google Sheets spreadsheet that you fill in yourself. Most online journals are paid, but offer a free trial or a money-back guarantee so you can test them with your own trades.
Does a trading journal make you money?
No. A journal does not trade for you and guarantees no result. It helps you see your repeated mistakes (moved stop, overtrading, risk that grows after a streak) so you can fix them. It is a measuring tool, not a signal.
Which trading journal for MT4 and MT5?
Favor a tool that imports your trades automatically from MetaTrader, so you never retype anything. Tradezella and Tradeora both state MT4 and MT5 support. For the others, check the platform list on their site.
Want to see what your own trades are telling you? 14-day free trial, no credit card.
This comparison is written by the publisher of Tradeora. Edgewonk, Tradezella and TraderSync are trademarks of their owners and are not affiliated with Tradeora. This content is educational and is not investment advice. Trading involves a risk of capital loss.