Win rate and risk/reward ratio explained
Updated
Win rate is the statistic traders look at most, and probably the one they misread most. On its own, it says almost nothing about whether a strategy makes money. Here are the numbers to read alongside it to know whether your trading is really profitable.
Win rate alone isn't enough
Take two traders:
- Trader A wins 40% of their trades. When they win, they make on average 2 times what they risk. When they lose, they lose 1 times their risk.
- Trader B wins 70% of their trades. But they cut their winners early (0.4 times their risk on average) and let their losers run to the stop (1 times their risk).
At first glance, B looks better. In reality, A makes money and B loses it. One formula is enough to see why.
Expectancy
Expectancy = (win rate × average win) − (loss rate × average loss)
Expressing wins and losses as multiples of your risk (often written "R"):
- Trader A: (0.40 × 2) − (0.60 × 1) = +0.20 R per trade
- Trader B: (0.70 × 0.4) − (0.30 × 1) = −0.02 R per trade
Over 100 trades risking $100 each, A makes $2,000 on average and B loses $200, despite a win rate nearly twice as high.
The minimum win rate for your ratio
For any given risk/reward ratio, there's a win rate below which you're bound to lose money (before fees):
Break-even win rate = 1 ÷ (1 + ratio)
- 1:0.5 ratio → you need to win more than 66.7% of trades
- 1:1 ratio → more than 50%
- 1:2 ratio → more than 33.3%
- 1:3 ratio → more than 25%
Make sure you use your actual ratio, calculated from your history, not the one you aim for when opening positions. Early exits out of fear and stops moved out of hope almost always pull the real ratio down. It's one of the most common trading mistakes.
Profit factor
Profit factor is another way to read the same reality:
Profit factor = total gains ÷ total losses
A profit factor of 1 means you're breaking even; below that, you're losing. Trader A in the example has a profit factor of 0.8 ÷ 0.6 = 1.33. It's a good summary indicator, but it has the same flaw as expectancy: it says nothing about the path you took to get there. For that, look at your maximum drawdown. The benchmarks to know and the calculation traps are covered in the dedicated profit factor article.
Enough trades to draw conclusions
None of these statistics means anything over 15 trades. A win rate measured on a small sample can swing hugely by pure chance. As a rule of thumb, wait for at least 50 to 100 trades with the same rules before judging a strategy, and be wary of changing methods halfway through, which mixes several strategies into the same numbers.
Read the numbers together
Win rate tells you how often you're right, your actual ratio tells you how much you make when you're right, and expectancy and profit factor tell you whether the whole thing is profitable. It's the combination of all three, calculated on your full history, that tells you whether your strategy deserves to be kept, or fixed.